Light theme

Red Dead Redemption 2 review
Exceptional
by JonyBCN

Creo que no es necesario decir que este juego es enorme en todos los sentidos. El mundo está vivo, es apabullante ver interactuar todos los sistemas entre ellos y como todo funciona perfectamente cohesionado.
 
La única disonancia que le he encontrado es con el personaje principal. No por estar mal escrito, de hecho todo lo contrario, está planeado de forma excelente de principio a fin para unir al mundo creado y al jugador, sea cual sea su forma de jugar. Desde su mismo nombre, Arthur Morgan (Arturo/Morgana, el mismo juego te lanza a la cara varias comparativas Arturicas), muestra las contradicciones de el juego y jugador, adaptándose a ellas. La disonancia llega con lo encorsetarlo de la historia, que no cuadra con lo abierto del personaje.
 No cuadra, en demasiadas ocasiones la libertad del mundo abierto con tantísimas posibilidades con la lineanidad de la historia, y en ocasiones parecen 2 juegos en uno. La historia, eso sí, cumple al principio, destaca en el final del segundo acto, aunque más por las horas invertidas como jugador y el cariño hacia los personajes por el mismo motivo que por ella misma, y explota en el tramo final con Rockstar sabiendo dónde pinchar para tocar hueso y dejarte pidiendo más. El mundo, como decía, es apabullante, y premia constantemente al jugador que explora los rincones del mapa con pequeñas historias, y en su recta final homenajea a su precuela (secuela en realidad) de forma magistral.
«Blew my mind»
«Sit back and relax»
«That ending!»

Other reviews30

9.5/10

There is not much to say, this game is an epic, it really leaves us speechless with what it managed to achieve. Only the epilogue has a lower quality, because it is also too long in my opinion.
«Blew my mind»
«Constantly dying and enjoy it»
a truly amazing experience
«Blew my mind»
«Time-tested»
It's the best game I ever played. You absolutely fall in love with it, have compassion for Arthur, greatest character ever made. Absolutely amazing! 10/10
«Blew my mind»
«Just one more turn»
This game is what everyone wants on GTA V 
- Nobody bothers anyone
- the game chat is pretty funny considering the fact everyone talks with country accents
- no op weapons for no reasons
- gives everyone what they want
only flaw is that we cant have private sessions or director mode which is fine considering how everyone is in the lobby
8.5/10
«Blew my mind»
«Sit back and relax»
Red Dead Redemption 2 is the greatest video game ever made. I’ve never been more immersed in a game than in this wonderful western world.  The story was fantastic. Arthur Morgan is the best character a video game has ever had. The visuals of this game were spectacular (minus a few character models that weren’t bad, but were not great). The sound is great. The level of detail in this game has never been done before, whatever game is second place isn’t close.

Some people complained about the controls or feel for the game. I did not. The game makes you take deliberate actions but I found my Arthur Morgan was a badass gunslinger who didn’t have difficulty completing his tasks. Some people complained that this games pacing (specifically the opening) is too slow. I did not. I think the slow beginning forces you to pay attention to the incredible detail this game has to offer, and it does it in a way where you just think you are discovering things on your own.

This game took ~45 hours to complete and usually I am fatigued at that point and just pushing towards the finish line. I wasn’t fatigued. This game kept me fully engaged and entertained for that long, and it barely has any rpg mechanics. I wasn’t grinding for the next perk or upgrade or piece of equipment that makes my character better and gives me a sense of accomplishment. I was buying Arthur a sweet jacket and trimming his beard. I loved every minute of it. I don’t know how they pulled that off.

Final Score: A++
Read more...
Probably my number 1 of the decade. 
The greatest Western story ever told. Transcends its medium and becomes one of the greatest pieces ever made. Very few games have ever made me care so deeply for a character’s well being and wanting them to be the best person they can be. 
«Blew my mind»
«Just one more turn»
Masterpiece
Simply the greatest game ever made, which was my opinion when the first one was released. It's story is perfectly written and captivates you and sucks you in from the very begining to the very end. Outstanding!
«Blew my mind»
«Just one more turn»
Red Dead Redemption is a game I always remember. I was a year out of college and sort of didn't know what I was going to do with my life. I remember being down in the dumps a bit living with my roommate in Concord NH. I loved Rockstar games and remembering looking up Red Dead Revolver and it looking like a game I probably wasn't too interested in. I picked up Red Dead being skeptical and it ended up being one of my favorite games. A character you could become obsessed with, John Marston. 

Cut to 2019 and Red Dead Redemption has been replaced. That gunslinger I once loved has been replaced by a caring bad guy who is self-aware of the bad deeds he continues to do. He can't help himself and he knows that, which is probably why I love his character so much. With one of the realist villains I can remember with Dutch Van Der Linde and some of the most realistic gameplay in a videogame, I was enamored for 80 plus hours of gameplay. 

I can't wait to remember it again.
Red Dead Redemption was an interesting game but surely nothing groundbreaking. It had its own personality and taste but was brought down by its slow-paced, clunky and repetitive gameplay. This prequel is no difference.

Rockstar obviously put a lot of effort into creating an immersive and visually stunning setting. All locations are beautifully crafted, incredibly rich in detail, and full of things to do and places to explore. Like in most open-world games, the map is enormous just for the sake of it, with most events concentrated in the rather small cities and camps, but I guess that's how it really was back then. While graphics are impressive for a game of such scale, I wish they could work a bit more on at least the main characters' models. Facial animations and skin textures are pretty good, but hair mostly looks like something from a late seventh-generation game.

The story is nothing new but delivers: it's backed up by a lot of memorable, all-round characters, and writing, acting, and direction are top-notch for a videogame. It was great to meet the rest of Dutch’s gang and see their development throughout the 40+ hours of the campaign. The connection with the events of the original game is well thought, and Arthur is a surprisingly likable main character. It takes quite a considerable amount of gameplay to get to properly remember everyone, get attached to them and finally get sucked in, but it will pay off in the end.

The gameplay is incredibly outdated: controls are clumsy, unresponsive, and convoluted. Combat and shooting suffer the most as everything is as flat and clunky as it was in the first game over eight years ago.
Missions are repetitive, monotonous, and rarely rewarding. They can all be summed up as endless horse rides, shoot-outs, and fetching/moving objects with not much interaction. The game also decides to reset or change your inventory depending on the mission, leaving no room for strategy in selecting good equipment. The rest is just an endless list of way too many unnecessary and tedious chores to remember. Shaving, trimming, hunting for food, cooking, eating, cleaning weapons, wearing the right clothing, looting, collecting money, taking care of your horses, etc. Most of these tasks surely add realism but are not that much fun to play. The game also gives you the opportunity to donate part of your rewards and loots to the gang to update the camp, which I liked, but it's mostly minor graphic additions and some provisions which you can easily find in the game anyway.

Overall, I really enjoyed the story, setting and characters, but the monotonous and outdated gameplay needs a lot of improvement. It would still recommend this game if you like open-world experiences but this is far from being the masterpiece professional reviewers are talking about (7.2/10).
Read more...
The campaign was incredible, I'd never been so engrossed in a single-player experience. It's like a whole other life you live as Arthur Morgan.
«Can’t stop playing»
«That ending!»